The concept of becoming the Pirate King in the world of One Piece has sparked heated debates among fans, particularly regarding the necessity of alliances and external assistance in achieving this lofty goal.
A recent comparison between Luffy’s potential alliance against Kaido and the historical events involving Gol D. Roger and the World Government (WG) has stirred up passionate opinions.
This discussion revolves around the question of whether one can truly be considered the Pirate King if external help is enlisted in pivotal battles.
Independence and the Pirate King Title
A vocal subset of One Piece fans argues that the essence of being the Pirate King lies in one’s ability to stand independently and face challenges head-on without relying on external assistance.
Luffy, as the series protagonist, is seen by some as potentially compromising this notion if he needs the Navy or other allies to take down formidable foes like Kaido.
The Role of Alliances in the Pirate World
On the contrary, proponents of alliances contend that the world of One Piece is complex and dangerous, and forming alliances is a pragmatic approach to navigate the treacherous seas.
Pirates throughout history, including Gol D. Roger, have sought powerful allies to achieve their goals.
They argue that the Pirate King title should not be defined solely by individual strength but also by the ability to forge alliances and create a legacy.
Gol D. Roger’s Legacy
The example of Gol D. Roger’s alliance with the World Government to defeat the Rocks Pirates is cited as a turning point in the narrative.
Some fans express disillusionment with Roger’s legacy, claiming that needing the WG’s help against a formidable adversary raises questions about his status as the true Pirate King.
This viewpoint suggests that affiliations with the WG compromise the essence of being a free-spirited pirate.
Defining the Pirate King
The crux of the matter lies in the definition of the Pirate King itself.
Is it a title reserved for an individual who solely relies on their strength, or does it encompass those who can strategically form alliances to overcome insurmountable challenges?
The ongoing debate in the One Piece community reflects differing perspectives on what it means to be the Pirate King.